Supplier dossiers and ODM reports quote challenge-test results as a single word: PASS. The word hides three different bars. ISO 11930:2019 Criterion A, ISO 11930 Criterion B and USP 51 Category 2 differ by one logarithm and seven days — and on an audit day, that difference is the whole story.

The panel, the inoculum and the clock

Both tests challenge the product with the same five organisms — Staphylococcus aureus ATCC 6538, Escherichia coli ATCC 8739, Pseudomonas aeruginosa ATCC 9027, Candida albicans ATCC 10231 and Aspergillus brasiliensis ATCC 16404 — each at 10⁵–10⁶ CFU per gram or millilitre, incubated at 20–25 °C and read at 7, 14 and 28 days. The schedule matters more than the headline: Pseudomonas is the hardest of the three bacteria, and Aspergillus is the usual point of failure in water-rich formulas.

ISO 11930: Criterion A vs Criterion B

Organism groupCriterion ACriterion B
Bacteria (3 strains)≥3 log reduction by day 7; ≥3 log at day 14; no increase at day 28≥3 log reduction by day 14; no increase at day 28
Candida albicans≥1 log by day 7; ≥1 log at day 14; no increase at day 28≥1 log by day 14; no increase at day 28
Aspergillus brasiliensisNo increase from initial at day 14; ≥1 log by day 28No increase from initial at days 14 and 28

"No increase" means no more than 0.5 log above the previous count. Criterion A is the standard itself: a formula meeting A for all five organisms is considered adequately preserved as tested. Criterion B is legitimate only when the risk assessment in Annex B can point at something else doing part of the work — airless or single-dose packaging, a limited period after opening, or low-risk usage. A Criterion B pass on an open-jar product with no justification is an audit finding, not a pass.

USP 51 is a different, lower bar

USP 51 classifies products into four categories. For cosmetics the relevant one is Category 2 (topicals): bacteria need only a ≥2 log reduction by day 14 with no increase through day 28, and yeast/mold only no increase at days 14 and 28. A supplier quoting a "USP 51 pass" for a cosmetic is therefore quoting a weaker claim than ISO 11930 Criterion A — same organisms, same inoculum, one log less and seven days later. Neither result is wrong; they are different questions. EU safety assessments (CPSR) expect ISO 11930 because it is the method designed for cosmetics under Regulation 1223/2009.

When the test may not be needed at all

ISO 29621 lets low-risk products skip the challenge test. The physics behind it is water activity: published minimum aw values for growth are about 0.97 for P. aeruginosa, 0.95 for E. coli, 0.87 for C. albicans, 0.86 for S. aureus and 0.77 for A. brasiliensis — and formulations at or below 0.75 (anhydrous balms, high-glycerol or salt-heavy systems) fall outside the risk zone. Finished-product microbial limits are a separate document (ISO 17516); a clean release result never proves the preservative system works, it only proves the batch left clean.

What to demand with the report

  • Raw CFU at days 7/14/28 per organism, not a PASS logo — a 3.1 log pass on Pseudomonas is one reformulation away from failing.
  • The criterion (A or B) and, for B, the Annex B justification in writing.
  • Neutralization validation: the recovery method must be shown to inactivate the preservative, otherwise survivors are under-counted.
  • The retest triggers: any change of preservative, concentration, pH, water content, chelator, packaging or process invalidates the result; fragrance or colour tweaks usually do not.

How a preservative system is assembled is covered in the home-care preservative guide, and why the dosed concentration is not the effective concentration in the free-concentration guide.

We supply the backbone and the boosters: Phenoxyethanol (122-99-6) as the broad-spectrum backbone, 1,2-Hexanediol (6920-22-5) and Glyceryl Undecylenate (123759-97-7) as multifunctional boosters, ready-to-use blends YS-801 and YS-802 for personal care, YS-T10 (IPBC 55406-53-6; MIT 2682-20-4) for wet wipes, YS-812 for detergents and YS-MK (BIT 2634-33-5) for metalworking fluids.