One certificate says "Colour: 25". Another says "Saybolt +25". They are not the same number, and no published table turns one into the other. Colour is the cheapest quality signal on a COA and the easiest one to misread, because the scale itself is usually left off the line.

Three scales cover three colour ranges

ScaleRangeMethodTypical products
APHA / Pt-Co / Hazen0–500ASTM D1209 (visual), D5386 (instrumental)Solvents, alcohols, esters, surfactants, white oils
Saybolt+30 to −16ASTM D156 (chromometer), D6045Kerosene, naphtha, jet fuel, pharmaceutical white oils
Gardner1–18ASTM D1544Resins, varnishes, fatty acids, drying oils
ASTM Colour0.5–8ASTM D1500Lubricating oils, diesel, heating oil, waxes

APHA, Pt-Co and Hazen are three names for one scale: platinum-cobalt, with 0 assigned to distilled water and 500 to a pale yellow. A Chinese COA often prints it as 色度 with the unit Hazen, and it is the same figure as APHA. Saybolt runs the other way — +30 is the clearest oil and negative numbers are darker — so on a Saybolt spec higher is better, while on APHA lower is better. Reading the two with the same reflex is how a 25 becomes a rejection.

Why the conversion tables online are wrong

The APHA and Gardner scales overlap only at the pale end. An APHA 500 standard sits just under Gardner 2 (some sources place it between Gardner 2 and 3), so anything from Gardner 3 upward is darker than the entire APHA scale. A "conversion" from a Gardner 6 resin to an APHA number is not a conversion — it is an extrapolation with no standard behind it.

Saybolt is worse. Several sources repeat "Saybolt +25 equals APHA 25", and supplier literature quotes it freely, but the same sources concede that exact equivalencies are difficult to obtain because the two methods judge colour through different spectral responses. Treat +25 = 25 as one coincident point, not a formula. If a customer specifies Saybolt and the supplier reports APHA, ask for a retained sample to be re-tested in Saybolt; that takes a day and settles the argument.

What a colour line must contain

  • Scale and method. "APHA ≤ 20, ASTM D1209" is a specification. "Colour ≤ 20" is a wish.
  • Path length. APHA is read in a 10 mm cell as standard. A 50 mm cell makes a pale sample read darker by design, and some older methods use 25 mm or 40 mm.
  • Illuminant and observer for instrumental readings — D65 / 10° is the common pairing, and results drift when one lab uses another.
  • Sample temperature and cell condition. A hazy sample or a bubble on the glass scatters light and reads high; wipe the cell and degas before blaming the batch.

Colour is a trend, not a number

A single passing value tells you almost nothing. Colour is the earliest visible sign of oxidation, contamination or overheating: esters yellow as peroxide value climbs, white oils pick up colour from a dirty line or a hot tank, and ethoxylates darken when the reaction runs hot. If a supplier sits at 18–20 APHA against a 25 limit, ask for the last six batches. A slow climb passes today's test and fails the customer's.

Read colour next to peroxide value and acid value rather than alone: colour usually moves first, odour second, assay last. See our guide to peroxide, anisidine and TOTOX values on a COA for the numbers that pair with it.

Buying notes

  • Write scale, method and limit into the purchase order. If the COA arrives in a different scale, ask for a re-test, not a converted number.
  • Match the scale to the product: Saybolt for white oils, APHA for esters and surfactants, Gardner for fatty acids and resins.
  • Do not accept "water white" as a specification. It is a description, not a measurement.
  • Ask which instrument the lab uses. Two labs reading the same drum visually will disagree by several APHA units; two spectrophotometers usually agree within one.

We supply white mineral oil 22# cosmetic grade (CAS 8012-95-1) and 5# industrial grade (CAS 8042-47-5) with colour reported in Saybolt or APHA by method, plus isopropyl myristate (CAS 110-27-0), caprylic/capric triglyceride (CAS 65381-09-1), polysorbate 80 (CAS 9005-65-6), PEG-40 hydrogenated castor oil (CAS 61788-85-0), cetyl alcohol (CAS 36653-82-4), sorbitan stearate (CAS 1338-41-6), C12-13 alkyl lactate (CAS 93925-36-1) and citric acid anhydrous (CAS 77-92-9). Tell us the scale your customer tests to and we will quote against that scale.